Let’s talk Pinterest Strategy.
You were promised a 24/7 marketing machine, but your Pinterest account feels more like a ghost town. Maybe you’ve spent hours creating beautiful pins, only to watch them disappear into the void. Or perhaps you’ve followed all the “expert” advice about daily pinning, yet your analytics look like a flatline instead of the upward curve you were expecting.
Here’s the thing: Pinterest can absolutely be the sustainable marketing powerhouse you’ve dreamed of – one that brings in consistent traffic, leads, and sales while you focus on what truly matters in your business and life. But only if you understand what’s really holding you back (hint: it’s probably not what you think).
Let’s unpack why your current Pinterest strategy isn’t delivering the results you want and, more importantly, how to fix it without adding more to your already full plate.
Save post for late:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/96ca2/96ca271dfcb27f678a05f0e0c36437710ec8093d" alt="Pinterest pin with the text: how to create an effective Pinterest marketing strategy that converts"
The Truth About Pinterest Success
Before we dive into what’s broken, let’s clear up a crucial misconception: Pinterest isn’t social media – it’s a visual search engine. This fundamental misunderstanding is often the first domino in a series of strategic missteps.
When you approach Pinterest like Instagram or Facebook, you’re playing the wrong game entirely. You wouldn’t use the same strategy to rank on Google as you would to go viral on TikTok, right? The same principle applies here.
Pinterest’s success isn’t measured in daily engagement or viral moments. It’s built through strategic, sustainable practices that compound over time. Think of it less like a sprint and more like training for a marathon – steady, intentional progress wins every time.
What is a Pinterest Strategy?
So, what exactly is a Pinterest strategy? It starts with setting up a solid Pinterest profile and creating Pinterest boards that resonate with your ideal audience. Your pin descriptions should be rich in relevant keywords to boost visibility in search results. Since people use Pinterest for inspiration, your content needs to be engaging, eye-catching, and shareable. And with a Pinterest business account, you get access to invaluable Pinterest analytics, helping you track how your pins are performing.
To take it a step further, consider using Pinterest ads to reach a wider audience and drive traffic to your site. Pinterest SEO is also crucial – optimizing your content for the Pinterest algorithm can significantly improve your chances of getting noticed. To keep things consistent, schedule your pins to ensure a steady flow of content. By staying on top of Pinterest trends and applying effective Pinterest marketing strategies, you can build a successful Pinterest marketing plan over time. Just remember, it’s not just about creating pretty pins; it’s about crafting a Pinterest strategy that truly connects with your target Pinterest audience and drives meaningful engagement.
The Top 5 Strategy Killers (And Their Solutions)
Misaligned Content Strategy
You’re creating pins, but are they actually serving your business? Many creators fall into the trap of pinning without purpose, creating content that looks pretty but doesn’t connect to their offers or business goals.
The Fix: Start with your end goal and work backward. Every pin should be part of a clear path leading to your offers. Map out content themes that directly align with your products or services. For instance, if you sell website templates, your pins shouldn’t just showcase design inspiration – they should address the specific problems your templates solve.
SEO Blindspots
Pinterest is a search engine first, which means keyword research isn’t optional – it’s essential. If you’re using creative, clever titles instead of searchable keywords, you’re essentially hiding your content from your ideal clients.
The Fix: Invest time in keyword research. Use Pinterest’s search bar to find what your ideal clients are actually searching for. Pay attention to the suggested terms that appear and incorporate them naturally into your pin titles, descriptions, and board names. Remember, clarity trumps creativity when it comes to getting found.
Inconsistent Pinning Habits
The feast-or-famine approach to Pinterest – pinning 50 times one day and then disappearing for weeks – is killing your momentum. Pinterest rewards consistent activity, not sporadic bursts.
The Fix: Create a sustainable pinning strategy that you can actually maintain. This might mean pinning just 3-5 times per day through a scheduling tool rather than trying to manually pin 20+ times daily. The key is consistency over quantity.
Poor Pin Design Strategy
Generic templates and mismatched branding aren’t just aesthetic issues – they’re conversion killers. Your pins need to stop the scroll and communicate value in seconds.
The Fix: Develop a signature pin design that aligns with your brand but stands out in the Pinterest feed. Focus on:
- Clear, readable text
- Strong visual hierarchy
- Brand colors and fonts that differentiate you
- High-quality images that resonate with your audience
Weak Backend Systems
Even if you’re getting clicks, a weak backend system means you’re losing potential clients. Without proper tracking and funnel setup, you can’t convert that Pinterest traffic into actual results.
The Fix: Set up systems to capture and nurture Pinterest traffic:
- Install proper analytics tracking
- Create landing pages specific to Pinterest traffic
- Develop lead magnets that align with your Pinterest content
- Implement email sequences that guide visitors toward your offers
The Sustainable Fix: Your Path Forward
Creating a Pinterest strategy that actually works (while you rest) doesn’t happen overnight, but it is possible with the right framework. Here’s your action plan:
Audit and Align
Start by reviewing all the content you’ve created. Identify which pieces align with your products or services, and assess how well they engage your audience.
Next, evaluate how each piece of content is performing. Look at key metrics such as impressions, saves, and clicks. This will show you what resonates with your audience and lead them to take action.
Think about any gaps in your content. Are there topics you haven’t covered that could strengthen your offers? For example, you might want to create articles that highlight the benefits of your products or address common problems your audience faces.
Also, consider your customer’s journey. Map how your content fits into the stages of awareness, consideration, and decision-making. Make sure your content adds value at each stage, helping guide potential customers toward making a purchase.
By reviewing your content and aligning it with your offers, you’ll create a more effective marketing plan that attracts and retains customers.
Save for later:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/38a02/38a0218af681ea2f9920aafb2536dc22fbfd60e2" alt="Pinterest pin with the text: why a keywords strategy is important with Pinterest"
Develop Your Keyword Strategy
Building a strong keyword strategy is essential for driving traffic and visibility on Pinterest. Start by creating a master list of relevant keywords that are closely aligned with your business, products, or services. Use tools like the Pinterest search bar to discover what terms Pinterest users are searching for. These keywords should be incorporated consistently across your Pinterest profile, Pinterest boards, and individual pins to ensure your content is discoverable in search results.
It’s important to use these keywords in key areas like pin descriptions, board names, and your Pinterest bio. This helps your content appear in Pinterest’s search engine and get seen by the right Pinterest audience.
Don’t forget to regularly update your keyword list. As trends evolve and Pinterest trends change, new searches on Pinterest may emerge, so staying on top of keyword research is key. This ensures your content remains relevant and gets found by your ideal customers. Over time, this strategic use of Pinterest SEO can dramatically improve the performance of your Pinterest content and help you create a successful Pinterest marketing strategy.
Create a Content Batching System
One of the most effective ways to stay consistent on Pinterest is by creating a content batching system. Rather than scrambling to create Pinterest posts on the fly, set aside dedicated time each month to create your Pinterest content in bulk. This approach not only makes the process more efficient but also ensures that your content is cohesive and aligned with your business goals.
To make things easier, use Pinterest templates to streamline the creation of your pins. These pre-made designs can be customized with your brand colors, fonts, and images, which helps maintain brand consistency while speeding up the design process. By creating a bank of pins in advance, you’ll have fresh, shareable content ready to go without feeling overwhelmed by the constant need to produce.
Once you’ve created your batch of pins, schedule them using a Pinterest scheduling tool to ensure a steady flow of content on your Pinterest feed. This approach helps you maintain consistency with your pinning strategy and prevents periods of inactivity that can hurt your performance on the platform.
By batching your Pinterest posts, you’re not just saving time; you’re also making it easier to optimize your Pinterest strategy over the long term. Regularly monitor the performance of your content through Pinterest analytics to see which pins perform best and tweak your approach accordingly. This helps you stay aligned with Pinterest marketing tips and ensures that you’re consistently driving traffic and engagement toward your business.
Automate Your Pinning
Consistency is key when it comes to a successful Pinterest marketing strategy, and automating your pinning can help you maintain that consistency without spending all day on the platform. A Pinterest scheduling tool allows you to queue up multiple Pinterest posts in advance, so your content is regularly published even when you’re not actively pinning. This makes it easy to maintain a consistent pinning schedule, ensuring your Pinterest feed stays fresh without requiring constant attention.
By scheduling your pins, you’re freeing up valuable time for other tasks while still benefiting from the steady, long-term results Pinterest can provide. You can plan your pinning strategy around your business goals and ensure you are always hitting your target audience at the right times. Make sure to schedule your Pinterest content across different boards and pin types to maximize visibility. Pinterest allows you to reach a wider audience by diversifying the types of pins you create, whether they’re standard pins, video pins, or carousel pins.
Automating your pinning also ensures that you remain in line with the Pinterest algorithm, which rewards consistent activity. Scheduling allows you to stay active across social channels without needing to be glued to your screen. As you continue to optimize your Pinterest strategy, automated pinning will keep your content circulating, increasing your chances of getting discovered by new Pinterest users and driving more traffic to your site.
Track and Optimize
Tracking your results is essential for understanding what’s working on Pinterest and what needs improvement. Pinterest analytics provides valuable insights into how your pins are performing, who’s engaging with them, and how they’re contributing to your business goals. Set aside time each month to dive into your Pinterest analytics and assess the performance of your content. Look at metrics such as click-throughs, email signups, and sales to understand how your content is driving actual results. These key metrics are much more valuable than focusing solely on repins or likes.
Pay attention to Pinterest trends and how they influence your Pinterest feed. Are there certain types of pins or content that are getting more engagement than others? Take note of the keywords and themes that are performing well. Adjust your Pinterest SEO strategy accordingly by adding relevant keywords to your pin descriptions, board titles, and profile, ensuring your content is fully optimized for the Pinterest search engine.
Over time, you’ll want to optimize your Pinterest marketing plan based on the data. Regularly monitor how your Pinterest business account is performing and tweak your pinning strategy based on these insights. By tracking your results and optimizing your approach, you’ll continually improve the effectiveness of your Pinterest marketing efforts, ensuring your content resonates with your target audience and drives valuable traffic to your site.
A Sustainable Pinterest Strategy
The truth is, Pinterest can be the sustainable marketing tool you’ve been looking for – one that brings in leads and sales while you focus on serving clients, creating new offers, or simply enjoying more time away from your business.
The key is shifting from reactive, time-intensive strategies to proactive, systematic approaches that work for you around the clock.
Ready for a Pinterest Strategy That Actually Works?
If you’re tired of trying to figure this out on your own, I get it. That’s exactly why I created my Pinterest management service. We handle everything – from SEO research to pin creation to strategic scheduling – so you can focus on what you do best.
Imagine waking up to consistent traffic, qualified leads, and sales that came in while you were offline. That’s not just possible; it’s exactly what my clients experience every day. Ready to turn your Pinterest account into a 24/7 marketing machine? Let’s talk about how we can make that happen for your business. Click here to learn more about my Pinterest management services and schedule a call.